+2776 329 9403
saisi@instsi.co.za
SAISI Member Area
My Cart
My Account

Ethical Dilemmas

by | Jul 21, 2021

Today’s blog post is the third in our series on ethics, written by Dana Katz, who holds the ethics portfolio on SAISI’s board.

What is an Ethical Dilemma?

At one time or another, we will all find ourselves in a bit of a pickle, having to make a difficult decision about a client or a situation that arises. This can be with regards to resources, therapy, colleagues, billing or any number of issues. We find ourselves stuck and not knowing what to do. How do we what is right, what isthe right thing to do?

An ethical dilemma exists when no single good solution can be found. It may be a conflict of “goods”. It may be a situation in which there are often a few solutions, none of which appear to be the ideal solution though. So what do we do?

An ethical dilemma can be characterized by:

  • Uncertainty – which moral or ethical principles do we apply
  • Distress – Knowing the right action but feeling constrained to act
  • Dilemma – Facing two or more alternatives, i.e. having two possible ethical principles that are in conflict with one another

An ethical dilemma may occur in practice in any of (but not limited to) the following instances:

  • Where a conflict of interests exists:

A conflict of interest occurs when a therapist’s personal interests or concerns are inconsistent with the best interests of the child/client. If a therapist receives any unearned benefit, a conflict of interest may be suspected.

It is important to be aware of personal relationships with clients or parents of clients. It can be rather challenging to identify conflicts of interests in these instances as we can become emotionally involved with the family or the child. In these instances or when family or friends are treated, one needs to be very aware of a personal bias influencing one’s actions, clinical reasoning or decision making.

Any time that a pattern of preference emerges that cannot be ethically explained, a conflict of interest may exist.

Conflict of interest can also include:

  • Giving or receiving any compensation, gift, reward, or gratuity from any source other than payment made for professional services provided to clients
  • Disclosing confidential information gained because of the therapist’s position, or otherwise using confidential information for personal gain or benefit.
  • When deciding whether to withhold / withdraw treatment.
  • When an invasion of privacy/breach of confidentiality occurs in team information sharing, especially in the school setting. Confidentiality and informed consent are of the utmost importance here.
  • Where resource allocation is challenging / limited or resources are shared – more specifically noted in a hospital or clinic setting – who gets what?
  • When a therapist’s personal views, morals or values are in conflict with their professional obligation/commitments.
  • When there is conflict between a client’s / parents’ request and what you believe to be required/best practice in the therapeutic process.
  • When there is conflict in deciding which treatment methodology/approach is best for a child.

How do we solve an ethical dilemma if it arises?

In order to solve an ethical dilemma one has to look at the problem systematically and objectively. It is often valuable to get someone who is not personally or emotionally involved in the situation to help with the process. There are various ethical approaches that represent ways in which we can evaluate situations, make decisions and ensure that we follow the most ethical course of action. Some of the more common approaches are described below.

The Utilitarian Approach

When using this approach, the consequences of the therapist’s actions are carefully weighed up. It is based on the principle of common good – “what is best for the majority?” This is observed to be one of the most common approaches to ethical decision making. The best action here will be the one that does the most good and the least harm.

The Rights Approach

This notes that the best ethical action is one that protects the rights of the individual/s affected by the action. “Does the action respect or violate the moral rights of the client?”

In order to ensure that we are protecting the rights of a child or their family, we can review the following documents:

  • UN convention on the Rights of the Child
  • Human Rights Charters
  • Patients’ Rights Charters

The Deontological Approach

This approach is non-consequential /duty based, i.e. it is about doing(or not doing)or basing your decision, on what is universally believed to be right and not about the consequences of our actions.  It states that is our duty to do good – having the correct intention when performing the action is what counts in this approach. Here the ethical action is taken because it is our obligation to perform the action based on rules or principles that apply. It follows rules of behaviour that are not contradicted by reason.

The Virtue Based Approach

This approach is agent centered, it asks the question “What kind of person should I be? It is concerned with one’s whole life and states that ethical actions should be consistent with human virtues. It emphasizes people of good character / virtuous people –it upholds honesty, faithfulness, courage, integrity etc. This approach values role models to support our understanding of ethical deliberation.

 

Models of Decision Making

There are a number of models that can be found to help us to think clearly about the process of making an ethical decision. We need to ensure that we have all the relevant information, clinical facts, wishes of the client etc. clearly stated. We need to ensure that we understand the legal perspective if required. We need to ensure that all stakeholders’ views are represented. We need to explore alternatives and look critically at the outcomes of our actions, evaluate the impact and only then make a decision that we can comfortably stand by.

 

 

Attached is a worksheet that will help you work through this process when you are faced with an ethical dilemma.  Take it slowly, step by step, then put it aside and have another look at a later stage with a clear head.  Click here to access the pdf.

Blog Author

Recent posts

Browse the past Blog posts

Related blogs

Autism in Focus 2026: Looking Beyond What We See

Different perspectives, fresh insights and a reminder that there’s always more to learn.
What does it really mean to understand an autistic child? Is it about recognising certain behaviours, knowing the diagnostic criteria, or finding the right therapeutic approach? Or is it about something much bigger?

On 16 and 17 October 2026, the South African Institute for Sensory Integration (SAISI) hosted Autism in Focus 2026, a two-day online event bringing together therapists, healthcare professionals, parents and teachers to explore autism from different perspectives.

And what a variety of perspectives there were! From sensory integration, communication and DIRFloortime® to anxiety, demand avoidance, feeding, medical research and self-advocacy, there was plenty to think about.

But perhaps one of the most valuable messages was surprisingly simple: sometimes we need to stop focusing on what a child is doing and start wondering why.

There’s Always More Behind the Behaviour

We’ve all encountered a child who refuses an activity, struggles with transitions or becomes overwhelmed by something that seems relatively small. Our first instinct might be to ask, “How do we get this child to cooperate?”

But what if we asked a different question? What if we asked, “What is this child trying to tell us?”
Emma Wijnberg explored autism through a sensory integration lens, while Elize Janse van Rensburg’s presentation on anxiety, autonomy and demand avoidance encouraged consideration of the demands children face.

A child who refuses an activity might be anxious. A child who runs away might be overwhelmed by sensory input. A child who repeatedly asks the same question might simply be looking for reassurance.

The behaviour is what we see. Understanding what lies beneath it is where meaningful support begins.

One of the most powerful concepts highlighted in the event’s educational material was the invisible load autistic children may carry throughout their day. Imagine a child arriving at school with an empty backpack. Throughout the day, we add a book for every demand: classroom noise, social expectations, following instructions, managing transitions, concentrating and coping with unexpected changes.

By home time, that schoolbag is pretty heavy!

Yet, from the outside, the child may appear to have had a perfectly good day. Some children with Autism also mask their difficulties, working incredibly hard to fit in, follow expectations and appear as though they are coping.

And then they get home.

The tears start. The frustration spills over. Perhaps there’s a meltdown over something seemingly insignificant. But was it really about that small thing? Or was it the weight of everything that came before it? It leaves us with a question worth remembering:

Instead of asking, “Can this child cope?”, perhaps we should ask, “What is it costing them to cope?”

Different Approaches, One Child

What made Autism in Focus particularly interesting was the variety of professional perspectives.

Jessie-Anne Bird explored the identification of autism and SPELL principles, while Belinda von Wielligh introduced the relationship-based DIRFloortime® approach, reminding us of the importance of connection and meaningful play. Dr Gina Rencken provided a perinatal perspective on autism and early neurodevelopment.

Rochelle Thanjan highlighted neurodiversity-affirming communication, while
Kath Megaw explored feeding differences, sensory regulation and gut–brain links.
The programme also ventured into medical territory, with Dr Nerica Ramsundhar discussing emerging research involving leucovorin, and Prof Wattie Janse van Rensburg addressing the ethics of genetic testing.

Dr Andy Hoffmeyer discussed medication as a possible support for neurodivergent children, while Jessica Jansen van Rensburg considered low-demand parenting and the use of visual schedules.

Another important contribution came from Dr Emile Gouws, who brought the conversation back to autistic voices, self-advocacy and the broader neurodiverse community. He shared his own experiences as a young non-verbal child who was later diagnosed on the autism spectrum.

There were so many different perspectives, yet all encouraging us to see the child as more than a diagnosis or a collection of challenges, because there is no single approach that fits every autistic child. Understanding the individual will always matter.

Not every professional development event needs to introduce something completely new. Sometimes, hearing a familiar idea explained differently is enough to make us reconsider how we approach our work. This was beautifully captured by therapist Serna Smit, who shared:

“Autism in Focus was a valuable and inspiring event. Although not all the information was new, it encouraged me to reflect on my therapeutic approach and reignited my passion for learning. The discussions on PDA, diagnosis and Floortime were particularly insightful.
The online format was convenient, the cost affordable, and the CPD points an added bonus! Access to the presentation slides afterwards would have been appreciated.
Overall, a wonderful reminder that even experienced therapists always have something new to learn!”

And isn’t that exactly what professional development should do?

The convenient online format, affordable cost and CPD accreditation made the event accessible, while the opportunity to revisit familiar concepts through different lenses added real value.

Taking It Back to the Children

At the end of the day, the value of an event like Autism in Focus lies in what we take back into our therapy rooms, classrooms and homes. Perhaps it’s being a little more curious before responding to a child’s behaviour. Perhaps it’s recognising that the child who looks perfectly fine at school might be working harder than we realise. Or perhaps it’s remembering that connection, predictability, autonomy and feeling understood can be just as important as the skills we’re trying to teach.

Our goal shouldn’t simply be children who look as though they’re coping. It should be children who genuinely feel safe, supported and understood.

Autism in Focus 2026 was a valuable opportunity to reflect, reconsider and keep learning. Because whether we’ve been practising for two years or twenty, there is always something more to discover about the children we support.

And sometimes, a small change in how we look at a child can make a big difference in how we support them.

Homework Headache: 

Homework Headache: 

Sensory Strategies to Help  Homework time can be difficult for many families. Your child may leave the table constantly, rock on his or her...